The sharing economy: using cleft sentences for emphasis
1
Think about these questions before reading. Share your ideas with a partner.
- Reflecting on services like Airbnb or ride-sharing apps, what are the key factors that either build your trust or fuel your skepticism about engaging with strangers in a commercial transaction?
- How do you think the rise of the 'gig economy', often underpinned by sharing platforms, is reshaping traditional career paths and notions of job security in your country?
- The sharing economy promotes the idea of 'access over ownership'. In what aspects of your own life has this shift become a reality, and what possessions, if any, would you be completely unwilling to share or rent out?
2
The Sharing Economy Debate
Listen to the dialogue. Notice how the vocabulary and grammar from the lesson are used.
3
Answer these questions in your own words. Support your answers with evidence from the article.
01In what way does the article suggest the sharing economy represents a 'paradigm shift' in consumer behaviour?
Sample answerIt portrays it as a fundamental move away from traditional ownership towards a model based on access. Rather than everyone needing to buy their own products, the focus shifts to sharing resources, which is a completely different mindset about consumption.
02According to the article, what role do 'underutilized assets' play in the sharing economy model?
Sample answerThey are the core component. The entire concept is built on monetizing items that people own but don't use constantly, like a car that's parked most of the day or a spare bedroom. It's about unlocking the economic value of these otherwise idle assets.
03How does the article explain the connection between modern technology and the principles that underpin the sharing economy?
Sample answerIt suggests that technology is the crucial enabler. While sharing itself isn't new, it's the act of leveraging digital platforms, apps, and GPS that makes it possible to connect providers and users on a massive scale, efficiently and with a degree of trust.
04Beyond financial gains, what wider problems does the article imply the sharing economy helps to mitigate?
Sample answerThe article hints that it mitigates environmental strain by promoting more efficient use of existing goods, which could reduce the need for mass production. It also suggests a social benefit, potentially fostering a greater sense of community by connecting people through peer-to-peer transactions.
4
Vocabulary
Vocabulary
These expressions will help you communicate more naturally about this topic.
Examples
Disruptive innovation — an innovation that significantly alters the way consumers, industries, or businesses operate, often displacing established market leaders.
A business/tech term. Use it to describe technologies or business models that completely change an industry. For example, 'Ride-sharing apps were a disruptive innovation in the personal transport sector.'
To monetize an asset — to generate revenue from something you own, especially something that was not previously earning money.
This is a concise, semi-formal way to say 'make money from something'. It's a key concept in the sharing economy, which allows people to monetize underutilized assets like a spare room or a car.
Regulatory grey area — a situation where the law is unclear or does not specifically address a particular issue, making it uncertain what is legal.
Often used in discussions about new technologies. You can say something 'operates in' or 'exists in' a regulatory grey area. For example, 'Many early sharing economy platforms operated in a regulatory grey area.'
To lower the barrier to entry — to make it easier for new individuals or companies to start providing a service or participating in a market.
A common phrase in business and economics. It explains how a new system removes obstacles (like high costs or complex licensing). For example, 'These platforms lower the barrier to entry for becoming a freelance host.'
Peer-to-peer (P2P) — relating to a network in which individuals share resources or services directly with one another without the need for a central intermediary.
Used as an adjective, as in a 'peer-to-peer platform' or 'peer-to-peer lending'. It emphasizes the direct connection between users, which is a fundamental principle of the sharing economy.
5
Business and innovation collocations
The sharing economy has introduced new ways of talking about business. Complete the phrases below.
Match the beginning of each phrase on the left with its correct ending on the right.
Drag or click to match
Definitions
6
Grammar: Cleft sentences
Grammar
Cleft sentences are used to add emphasis to a particular part of a sentence by splitting a single clause into two. They are especially useful in discussions about complex topics like the sharing economy, as they allow you to highlight the most crucial aspect of your argument or clarify a specific point.
Examples
It's the potential for income generation that attracts so many people to the sharing economy.
Use 'It is/was...' to emphasize the subject or object. This structure focuses on 'the potential for income generation' as the primary motivator.
What critics often overlook is the impact on traditional industries and local regulations.
Use 'What...' to highlight the action or concept. This form brings attention to 'the impact' as the key point being missed.
The reason why these platforms have grown so quickly is their ability to leverage underutilized assets.
This structure specifically emphasizes the cause or reason for a situation, making your explanation more direct and forceful.
Key points
- Cleft sentences change the focus of a sentence, not its fundamental meaning.
- The most common structures begin with 'It...', 'What...', 'The thing that...', and 'The reason why...'.
- Avoid overusing them in writing or speech; their power comes from being used selectively for emphasis.
7
Find the mistake
Each sentence contains one error. Find and correct it.
01The rise of peer-to-peer platforms has had a deeply disrupting effect on the hotel and taxi industries.
Corrected version
The rise of peer-to-peer platforms has had a deeply disrupting disruptive effect on the hotel and taxi industries.
02What worries regulators most are the lack of consumer protection in these new business models.
Corrected version
What worries regulators most are is the lack of consumer protection in these new business models.
03The entire sharing economy model is underpinned with the idea that trust can be built between strangers online.
Corrected version
The entire sharing economy model is underpinned with by the idea that trust can be built between strangers online.
04Many startups initially operated in a regulatory grey zone, which caused friction with local governments.
Corrected version
Many startups initially operated in a regulatory grey zone, area, which caused friction with local governments.
05It is the leveraging of underutilized assets why these platforms have become so profitable.
Corrected version
It is the leveraging of underutilized assets why that has made these platforms have become so profitable.
06By connecting people directly, these apps significantly lower the barrier to enter for aspiring entrepreneurs.
Corrected version
By connecting people directly, these apps significantly lower the barrier to enter entry for aspiring entrepreneurs.
07The ability to monetize an asset which was previously just sat in your garage is a key appeal of the P2P model.
Corrected version
The ability to monetize an asset which was previously just sat sitting in your garage is a key appeal of the P2P model.
8
Useful phrases: Constructively debating a controversial topic
Vocabulary
When discussing complex, multi-faceted topics like the sharing economy, it's essential to do more than just state your opinion. The following phrases will help you navigate a formal debate or meeting, allowing you to acknowledge others' points, introduce nuance, and disagree respectfully.
Examples
"I take your point about [specific issue], but we also need to consider..." — Acknowledges the other person's argument before introducing a counter-argument.
Register: Formal/Neutral. Use this to show you've listened carefully before presenting a different angle. It makes your counter-argument seem more reasonable and less confrontational. Example: 'I take your point about the precarious nature of gig work, but we also need to consider the flexibility it offers people.'
"Granted, [concession], but that shouldn't overshadow..." — Strategically agrees with a part of the opposing argument to strengthen your main point.
Register: Formal/Neutral. This is a sophisticated debate tactic. By conceding a minor point ('granted'), you appear reasonable, which can make your main argument seem more credible. Example: 'Granted, there are data privacy concerns, but that shouldn't overshadow the huge gains in consumer convenience.'
"I think the issue isn't quite so black and white." — Signals that you are about to introduce a more complex or multifaceted perspective.
Register: Neutral. Use this when you feel the discussion is becoming oversimplified (e.g., just 'good vs. bad'). It's a gentle way to challenge the current framing of the issue and add depth to the conversation.
"Ultimately, it all comes down to..." — Refocuses the discussion on what you believe is the most fundamental aspect of the topic.
Register: Neutral. A powerful way to steer the conversation back to your main argument or to summarize the core conflict. Example: 'Ultimately, it all comes down to whether we prioritize market disruption or worker stability.'
"If we follow that line of thinking, we could inadvertently..." — Explores the potential negative long-term consequences of a particular viewpoint.
Register: Formal/Neutral. This is a way of challenging an idea by showing its potential future implications, without directly saying 'that's a bad idea'. It encourages deeper thought about the consequences.
"Could I just add something on that point?" — A polite way to interject with a relevant comment.
Register: Neutral. More collaborative than a direct interruption like 'Let me stop you there'. Use it when your point directly builds on or counters what the other person has just said. It shows you're engaged with their specific argument.
9
The impact of the sharing economy
Read the passage about the sharing economy and its effects on markets and regulations.
Fill in each blank with the correct word or phrase from the word bank.
Word bank
The rise of the sharing economy represents a genuine , fundamentally changing how we access goods and services. What these platforms excel at is enabling individuals to that might otherwise sit idle, like a spare room or a car. This model significantly for would-be entrepreneurs, allowing them to compete with established businesses. However, it's the very novelty of this model that often places it in a tricky , forcing cities and governments to adapt their laws. It is precisely this tension between innovation and regulation that much of the debate surrounding the platform economy's future.
10
The challenges of integration
Read the passage below, then answer the comprehension questions.
The initial promise of the peer-to-peer (P2P) economy was one of empowerment, allowing individuals to finally monetize an asset that might otherwise sit idle. This model didn't just offer a new service; what it represented was a genuine disruptive innovation that fundamentally challenged established industries like hospitality and transport. By dramatically lowering the barrier to entry, these platforms enabled almost anyone with a spare room or a car to become a micro-entrepreneur. However, this rapid expansion has exposed significant friction. It is the very speed and scale of this growth that have caught city planners and regulators unprepared, pushing many operations into a complex regulatory grey area. While consumers often benefit from increased choice, municipalities now grapple with unintended consequences, from strained public infrastructure to concerns over fair labour standards. The central question is no longer whether this model will persist, but how it can be integrated responsibly into the urban fabric.
01According to the text, what was the initial promise of the peer-to-peer economy?
Sample answerIts initial promise was to empower individuals by allowing them to monetize assets that were not being used.
02What effect did 'lowering the barrier to entry' have on individuals?
Sample answerIt enabled almost anyone with a spare room or car to become a micro-entrepreneur.
03Why have city planners and regulators been caught unprepared by the sharing economy?
Sample answerThey have been caught unprepared because of the sheer speed and scale of its growth.
04What does the author imply by the phrase 'unintended consequences'?
Sample answerThe author implies that while the sharing economy brought benefits like choice for consumers, it also created unforeseen problems for cities, such as stress on infrastructure and issues with labour rights, which were not the original goal of these platforms.
11
Discuss these questions with a partner. Try to use vocabulary from the lesson.
- To what extent do you agree that many sharing economy platforms are a form of 'disruptive innovation' that simply exploits a 'regulatory grey area' to gain an unfair advantage over traditional businesses? Should they be held to the same standards?
- The ability to 'monetize an asset' has 'lowered the barrier to entry' for entrepreneurship. In your culture, how has this rise of 'peer-to-peer' commerce affected the traditional separation between personal life and work? Is there growing pressure for individuals to constantly seek new income streams?
- Looking forward, what do you predict will be the next major industry to be transformed by the sharing economy? Discuss the potential societal benefits and ethical pitfalls of allowing people to 'monetize' increasingly personal assets, such as their time, data, or even social connections.