High-stakes crime: speculating about possibilities

B2
90 min
Premium
1

Think about these questions before watching. Share your ideas with a partner.

  1. Think about heist movies or TV shows you've seen. Besides the act of stealing itself, what do you believe is the most difficult challenge for the criminals to overcome?
  2. If an object is described as 'priceless', what does that mean to you? Can something have immense cultural value but be almost impossible to sell?
  3. Imagine a criminal has successfully stolen a world-famous painting. What are their options afterwards? How could they possibly profit from something so recognizable?
2

Watch the video carefully. Pay attention to the main ideas and key details.

Video script107 segments · click a timestamp to jump

- Answer me this, how would you go about selling these?

These are the priceless royal jewels that were stolen

from Paris's Louvre in a recent audacious heist.

- This case was done by professional thieves.

It's not like that you wake up on Sunday morning thinking

I become a burglar, and let's start with the Louvre.

- The French culture minister said

that these jewels have immeasurable value,

but unfortunately immeasurable doesn't pay the bills.

- If they are going to sell this on the market,

then the thieves will get like 30% of that.

- So here are the decisions the thieves may face

if they're looking to profit from the heist,

and what fingerprints could be left behind.

The first and arguably the simplest option

would be to shift these jewels wholesale, completely intact.

Authorities value the complete pieces

at around $102 million, but getting full value

for these would be almost impossible

because if someone were to buy these pieces intact,

they're not just acquiring the jewels,

they're also implicit in the crime.

- If you touch these items and you get caught,

you're gonna be behind bars for many, many years.

- One theory is that the pieces were stolen to order

for a buyer to keep intact.

However, Arthur doesn't think that's likely.

- That the idea of somebody, some commissioner,

some kind of Dr No, a villain from the James Bond movies,

they don't exist.

They only exist in Hollywood movies.

- So if the thieves are going to try and extract any value

from their heists, their likely route

is sadly going to be breaking down these priceless pieces

into many smaller priceable pieces.

You're gonna have to give me a minute here.

The thieves would now be left with this,

and these are just some of the stones.

There's absolutely no way I'm cutting all of this out.

It's a mix of precious metals, pearls, emeralds,

sapphires, and diamonds, all of different sizes and cuts.

- We are talking here about objects that can transform

into something else with no link whatsoever

to the original theft.

- But some of these would be harder to shift than others.

The precious metals would be relatively easy to move,

just melt them down and they're pretty much untraceable,

but they're also not worth very much.

- The downset piece quite often was set with silver

on the top and a thin layer of gold behind,

the metal value in something like that would be negligible.

- [George] When it comes to the smaller stones.

- You couldn't identify them.

Old jewelry is being broken up all the time.

So those sort of diamonds are coming into the market.

- The challenge comes when trying

to sell some of these bigger, far more identifiable stones,

because this is very obviously this

and because these stones are old cut fashioned years ago,

using more rudimentary techniques,

they're potentially dateable,

which could also link them back to the stolen jewels.

- Those would be very hard, I think,

to sell on the open market these fancy cuts

because they're so unique to this piece.

- So in order to hide where this has come from,

you may have to cut it down to a new cut,

reducing the size of the stone by about 20 to 30%,

but making it far harder to trace.

- Could you recut one? No.

It's a very skilled task to recut a stone,

and takes years and years, and years of experience.

- [George] But there may be a way

that these stones could be identified

even if they've been cut

and it lies deep within the stone itself.

- Typically, stones can have a variety

of different conclusions.

They can have little crystals

of a different mineral trapped inside them.

You can have what are called healed cracks,

and feathers inside stones

and some of those cracks might have had fluid in them,

so you get what's called a fingerprint like effect.

If you were that familiar with them.

If you were a curator say,

and you'd lived with these pieces for years,

you certainly might recognize

some of the internal features in them.

There's not much you can do

to change the look of the pearls.

They're all unique shapes and you could, I think,

identify the pearls even once it's been dismantled.

- So is all hope lost?

Is there any chance of the jewels being recovered?

Well, there's one final option we haven't mentioned yet,

and that's that the thieves could get cold feet.

- I think they are scared now.

You know, we are talking about it,

the prime minister in France,

the president is talking about it.

Everybody is talking about this heist.

The ideal ending of the story

that these guys look at each other thinking,

maybe we should leave it on some corner in Paris, run away,

and hopefully the police will start looking

for other things.

3

Answer these questions in your own words. Support your answers with evidence from the video.

01According to the video, why would it be nearly impossible for the thieves to get the full value for the jewels if they sold them intact?
Sample answerBecause anyone who bought the complete pieces would also be involved in the crime. The video says they would be 'implicit in the crime' and could go to jail for a very long time. Also, one expert believes the idea of a secret, rich collector ordering the theft is just a fantasy from the movies.
02What makes selling the smaller stones and precious metals easier than selling the larger, more unique gems?
Sample answerThe video explains that the metals can just be melted down, which makes them untraceable, even though they aren't worth much. The small stones are also easy to sell because lots of old jewelry is always being broken up, so similar stones are common on the market and can't be easily identified.
03In what ways could the thieves' attempts to sell the most valuable stones actually lead back to the original crime?
Sample answerThe biggest stones are the most dangerous to sell because their old-fashioned cuts are unique and can be dated. Even if the thieves find a highly skilled person to recut them, an expert like a curator might still recognize them from their internal features, which are described as being like 'fingerprints' inside the stone.
04Besides the technical challenges of selling the jewels, what other major pressure might lead the thieves to abandon their plan?
Sample answerThe video suggests they might get 'cold feet' and become too scared to continue. The crime is so famous that everyone is talking about it, which creates a lot of pressure. This huge amount of attention could make them feel it's too risky to try selling anything, so the best option might be to just leave the jewels somewhere and run away.
4

Vocabulary

Vocabulary
These expressions will help you communicate more naturally about this topic.
to get away with (something) — to succeed in doing something wrong or illegal without being punished or caught.
Usage note: This is a common phrasal verb. You can use it for serious crimes ('He got away with the robbery') or minor misdeeds ('My colleague gets away with being late every day').
to cover one's tracks — to hide or destroy evidence of your activities so that no one can find out what you have done.
Usage note: This phrase is often used when discussing how criminals try to avoid capture. For example, 'The thieves wore gloves and wiped all surfaces to cover their tracks.'
the black market — an illegal system for buying and selling goods that are difficult or illegal to obtain.
Usage note: This is the key term for the illegal trade of items like stolen art, weapons, or controlled substances. For example, 'It's nearly impossible to sell such a famous piece, even on the black market.'
an inside job — a crime, especially a theft, committed with help from someone who works for the organization that is robbed.
Usage note: Use this phrase to speculate that someone with internal knowledge, like an employee, helped the criminals. For example, 'The police suspect it was an inside job because the alarm system was disabled.'
a person of interest — someone who the police think may have been involved in a crime, but who has not been arrested.
Usage note: This is a more formal term used by police and in news reports. It's more neutral than 'suspect' and suggests the investigation is still in its early stages.
5

Decide if each statement is true or false. Correct the false ones.

01The precious metals from the jewelry, such as gold and silver, are relatively easy to sell but are not considered highly valuable.
02According to one expert, the jewels were most likely stolen to order for a wealthy, anonymous collector.
03The video suggests that pearls would be particularly difficult to disguise because of their unique shapes.
04Recutting a large, unique gem can make it harder to trace, but this process significantly reduces its size.
05The internal 'fingerprints' of a stone, like cracks and crystals, can be removed by a skilled gem cutter to make it untraceable.
6

Complete the sentences with words from the box. One word is extra.

Word bank
01The thieves knew the exact location of the security cameras and when the guards changed shifts, leading police to believe it was an .
02After the robbery, the criminals meticulously wiped all surfaces and burned their clothes to .
03Although they haven't arrested him, the detective confirmed that the disgruntled former employee is a in the investigation.
04Stolen art and priceless jewels are often sold on the for a fraction of their real value.
05The mastermind behind the heist was so arrogant; he genuinely thought he could such a high-profile crime.
7

Choose the best answer based on what you heard in the video.

01According to one expert in the video, why is the theory of a 'stolen to order' heist for a private collector unlikely?
02What is the estimated percentage of the jewels' market value that the thieves could realistically expect to receive?
03Who does the video suggest might be able to identify the larger stones even after they have been recut?
04Which of the following methods for dealing with the stolen jewels is NOT mentioned as a possibility in the video?
8

Crime and consequences

Speculating about a crime involves thinking about motives, methods, and outcomes. How do these ideas connect?

Match the beginning of each sentence with its logical ending.

Drag or click to match
Definitions
9

Discuss these questions with a partner. Try to use vocabulary from the lesson.

  1. Some argue that if a priceless stolen artifact can't be recovered, it's better for it to be sold intact on the black market to a private collector than to be destroyed. Others disagree. What is your view and why?
  2. Think of a culturally significant object in your country. What security measures protect it, and do you believe a sophisticated team could get away with stealing it? Would it likely have to be an inside job?
  3. The video mentions the difficulty of covering one's tracks. Besides physical evidence, what kind of digital or financial trail might lead police to make someone a person of interest in a major heist today?